New York, NY vs Utica, NY: Crime Rate Comparison (2025)
A side-by-side look at reported crime in New York and Utica, on the FBI-based Crime Index (0–100, higher = safer) for 2025.
Utica is the safer city
Utica scores 55/100 (grade D) versus 51/100 (grade D) for New York — a 4-point gap. New York's violent-crime rate is +45% vs Utica. Across the 8 offense categories, Utica has the lower rate in 4.
New York, NY
Crime Index
- Population
- 8,496,850
- Violent / 100k
- 659
- Property / 100k
- 2,293
- In New York
- #10 of 15
Utica, NY
SaferCrime Index
- Population
- 63,288
- Violent / 100k
- 455
- Property / 100k
- 2,988
- In New York
- #9 of 15
Crime rates head-to-head
| Metric | New York | Utica | US average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crime Index (higher = safer) | 51D | 55D | 73C |
| Violent crime /100k | 659 | 455 | 315 |
| Property crime /100k | 2,293 | 2,988 | 1,487 |
| Homicide /100k | 3.3 | 3.2 | 4.1 |
| Total reported /100k | 2,951 | 3,443 | 1,802 |
Grade shown per index band (88–100 = A … 0–29 = F). Rates are reported offenses per 100,000 residents.
By offense
Rate per 100,000 residents — the lower (safer) city is highlighted.
| Offense | New York | Utica |
|---|---|---|
| Homicide | 3.3 | 3.2 |
| Rape | 41.1 | 77.4 |
| Robbery | 175 | 69.5 |
| Aggravated assault | 439 | 305 |
| Burglary | 151 | 281 |
| Larceny-theft | 1,951 | 2,539 |
| Motor vehicle theft | 183 | 150 |
| Arson | 7.7 | 17.4 |
Crime trends
New York
Utica
Frequently asked questions
Is New York or Utica safer?
Which has more violent crime, New York or Utica?
What are the odds of violent crime in New York vs Utica?
No area has zero risk
A high Crime Index score means lower reported crime relative to other US cities — it is not a guarantee of safety. Reported crime is not the same as actual crime. Research on the gap between crime that occurs and crime that gets reported to police — often called the "dark figure" of crime — estimates that roughly 40% of violent crime and about a third of property crime go unreported each year. Every index built on official statistics, including this one, necessarily undercounts real crime. That gap is exactly why homicide — the offense with the smallest dark figure — anchors the calculation instead of a more commonly reported but less reliable category like theft.
Scores on this page reflect FBI-reported data for 2025. See the full methodology →
Protecting yourself in New York & Utica
Worried about the numbers above? Compare local providers, estimate costs, and explore the right kind of coverage.